Who is the fattest?

Uhhhh I can't really explain this one. hahaha.

I think this might have been for someones birthday.
I think most peoples names said, "No, hes not the fattest. No cake for you"
Some said "Yep, hes the fattest, have some cake."
I think one name said, some else like, "oh yah he is the most fat the whole world" or something and had I different picture.

Why am I posting this one? Mostly just for the memories (for me). 2005 was a funny year, and this describes it prettty well. hahahaha.
This was the summer before my freshmen year in high school, what do you expect?